Saturday, January 3, 2009

Fine Just The Way It Is

Wyoming Stories 3
Annie Proulx

This is the first work I've read by the Pulitzer Prize winning author of The Shipping News. I suppose now I'll have to go ahead and read everything she's written. Not all at once, though.

Fine Just The Way It Is is a collection of short stories, mostly set in Wyoming, although there are two set in Hell, with the Devil as the central character. Maybe that's Proulx's real opinion of Wyoming? She visits 19th century homesteaders, an old cowboy in a nursing home, 21st century ranchers, back country hikers. Each has a story to tell and in each story the place is an important element.

Most of the characters seem to end up in a condition best described by the title of one of the stories Tits Up In A Ditch. They die in childbirth, catch pneumonia, get trapped by a falling rock high on a mountainside. Or old and tired in a nursing home, like Mr. Forkenbrock in the opening story, who would rather die of exposure, sitting with his back aginst a fence post, like an old man he remembers from his youth. Sitting comfortable on my sofa I can enjoy sympathizing with all these characters, knowing that they are fictional and I won't suffer brain damage from a roadside bomb in Iraq and be sent home to my unprepared parents on a ranch in the middle of nowhere.

I have the same objection to this book as I do with any well written collection of short stories. About the time that I really start to get involved with a group of characters, that story is over and I have to start over with a whole new set.

The title of the book comes from something said repeatedly by one of the characters, "Wyoming is fine just the way it is." Every story, although each reveals something beautiful about the state, show how very difficult it is to live there. It should be depressing, but it isn't.


  1. I don't know about Wyoming being hell. I thought the old peoples homes in Florida might approach it.

  2. I am not a short-story reader (although I probably should be) but this is completely intriguing. "Tits Up in a Ditch"??? That is just a priceless title for a story!!! I got a belly laugh over it. I may need to chase this down. Oh and by the way, no offense to anyone out there, but I think Vegas is a better location for the devil to hang out...

  3. Hello there my friend! I found your blog very interesting so I have added your link in my Blogroll. I hope you'll link me back. Have a nice day!

  4. Hi! Care to x-link? I have added you already in my list. Have a nice day!

  5. I just read the review and I needed to put the book on hold at the local library to read it.

  6. I loved Annie Proulx's first novel, "Postcards." I liked "The Shipping News" too. Enjoyed your review and am definitely adding this book to the ol' TBR stack.

  7. I have now read the book. It was very interesting. I know Wyoming is not depressing and I thought the stories were different. I did like the thought of the older man in the nursing home and I liked the story about the husband and wife who died. That was a story that could easily happen. Review more interesting books and I will read them too.


Comments will be moderated - so keep your comments moderate!

OpenID users will have their blog links again, yay!